Episode 44

full
Published on:

6th May 2025

Ep. 44: Science vs. Social Media: What the Evidence Actually Says About Muscle, Nutrition & Aging in Women

Is lifting heavy the only way to build muscle after 40? Does your menstrual cycle really need to dictate your workouts? And is fasting actually harming your hormones? In this powerhouse episode, we sit down with Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple, PhD—muscle physiology researcher and women's health expert—to set the record straight on some of the most common (and confusing) fitness myths shared on social media today.

From the real impact of estrogen on muscle adaptation to the truth about protein timing, cycle syncing, and Pilates vs. progressive overload—this conversation is a deep dive into what the science actually supports when it comes to strength training and aging well. Whether you're navigating perimenopause or just trying to cut through the chaos of social media advice, Dr. Colenso-Semple brings clarity, confidence, and evidence-based recommendations that empower you to take charge of your fitness with simplicity and confidence.

This episode will cut through the noise and guide you in how to train & eat to become strong, capable, and confident—at every age, in every phase.

--

IN THIS EPISODE:

00:00

Introduction to the Fit Physician Podcast

00:52

Dr. Lauren Colenso Semple's Background and Expertise

05:01

Empowering Women Through Evidence-Based Fitness

06:51

Debunking Myths: Heavy Weights vs. Muscle Growth

14:35

The Role of Hormones in Muscle Maintenance

16:22

Pilates and Its Effectiveness for Muscle Growth

20:28

The Importance of Force Production in Strength Training

25:30

Flexibility in Resistance Training: Finding What Works

27:54

Protein Timing and Nutrition for Women Physicians

28:08

Understanding Protein Timing and Nutrition

31:22

Debunking Myths Around Fasting and Menopause

39:27

The Impact of the Menstrual Cycle on Training

46:00

Core Foundations of Nutrition and Exercise

50:36

Future Directions in Women's Health Research

--

Connect With Us:


💪 Download Our Thriving Through Menopause Guide


📲 Follow Us On Instagram


💜 Learn More About Fit Physician Coaching

Listen for free

Show artwork for The Fit Physician

About the Podcast

The Fit Physician
Are you a busy woman in medicine looking to take your fitness and nutrition to the next level to thrive in all aspects of your life? Look no further! Welcome to The Fit Physician podcast.

As women in medicine, it’s your nature to care for others, often at the expense of your own physical and mental well-being. This can go on for months, even years. It’s time to put an end to this narrative, for all women physicians! And it starts now, with you, and The Fit Physician podcast!

Hosted by Jake Wright, BSc, a women’s fitness specialist with over 15 years of experience and joining him is, Dr. Suzanne Rutherford, MD, a practicing physician with an undergraduate degree in nutritional sciences. You’d be hard pressed to find two experts more passionate about empowering women physicians to live life to the fullest through prioritizing health and fitness.

Suzanne & Jake have dedicated the past 6 years transforming the lives of 100s of women in medicine such as yourself. Their passion for inspiring physicians shines through every episode, sharing stories, insights, expert advice, and providing actionable steps to prioritize yourself guilt-free.

So, if you're a busy woman physician ready to break free from the constraints of guilt, elevate your health, and become the best version of yourself, join Jake and Suzanne on The Fit Physician podcast. They're not just coaches; they're your partners in this transformative journey towards a life where you thrive, unapologetically.

Dr. Suzanne Rutherford, MD (Instagram: @slmmd1976)

Search the globe and it will be hard to find someone more dedicated to women physicians health & well-being than Suzanne.

A practicing physician, Suzanne combines her medical expertise with a foundation in nutritional sciences from her undergraduate studies.

Her passion lies in evidence-based nutrition and empowering fellow women physicians to embrace strength, health, and confidence in their own skin.

Suzanne doesn’t just talk the talk. After completing medical school and welcoming her second child into the world, she found herself facing personal health and fitness challenges that left her feeling like a stranger within her own body.

Determined to make a change, Suzanne rekindled her knowledge of nutrition while introducing strength training into her weekly routine.

The result? She lost over 30 lbs, has kept it off, and feels better in her 40s than she did in her 20s!

Now she spends the better part of her professional career helping other busy women physicians to achieve similar life-altering results.


Jake Wright, BSc

(Instagram: @thefitphysiciancoach Facebook: Jake Wright Facebook page: The Fit Physician Coach)

Meet Jake, also known as The Fit Physician Coach.

Jake’s experience includes a Bachelor of Science in kinesiology, over 15+ years as a women's fitness specialist, along with several advanced certifications in strength and condition, nutrition, and joint health.

For the past 6 years and counting, Jake has spent his career dedicated to inspiring busy women physicians to overcome barriers with time, energy, and the demands of their profession, to build a sustainable fitness routine that delivers life-changing results.

What separates Jake from the pack is not his education or his experience but his compassion.

Jake's gift is guiding women to discover strength they never thought possible. In turn, helping them to build confidence in the gym, in their bodies, and in every other aspect of their life.

About your host

Profile picture for Jake Wright

Jake Wright